Welcome to EragonHQ's official fan forum!
 
HomeHome  CalendarCalendar  FAQFAQ  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  Log inLog in  
http://eragonhq.weebly.com/ - GO THERE - Matt ~ EHQ
Latest topics
» Latest crack software ftp download
Sun Jan 19, 2014 8:55 am by asasq112

» Latest crack software ftp download
Sun Jan 19, 2014 8:54 am by asasq112

» Latest crack software ftp download
Sun Jan 19, 2014 8:54 am by asasq112

» Latest crack software ftp download
Sun Jan 19, 2014 8:53 am by asasq112

» Latest crack software ftp download
Sun Jan 19, 2014 8:52 am by asasq112

Top posters
Zeb (4559)
 
Simply Aravelle (3017)
 
eragon5217 (3010)
 
Emster (2608)
 
Fish Head (2554)
 
Rahl (2542)
 
Domia abr Wyrda (2063)
 
Elliot (1243)
 
DeltaFlip (976)
 
geniusevil (954)
 

Share | 
 

 Eragon+Nasuada

Go down 
Go to page : Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 5, 6, 7 ... 11, 12, 13  Next

Nasuada or Arya?
Nasuada
38%
 38% [ 5 ]
Arya
46%
 46% [ 6 ]
Someone else
8%
 8% [ 1 ]
He won't marry
8%
 8% [ 1 ]
Total Votes : 13
 

AuthorMessage
eragon5217

avatar

Posts : 3010
Join date : 2008-06-22
Age : 21
Location : VT

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Thu Oct 23, 2008 9:12 am

yes that is some GREAT evidence!

_________________
-Participant of the "I'm Mad" topic, that shall indeed save EHQ
-JOIN THE CAUSE! Keep the topic at the top of the list, without keeping it off topic, Matt if you're reading this, go there too. If you read it, reply, we need everyone's help!!

here is the link to the topic:
http://eragonheadquarters.forumakers.com/website-content-f11/i-m-mad-hey-matt-please-read-this-t408.htm
just so you know, I'm not Tom.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://eragonhq.com
eragon5217

avatar

Posts : 3010
Join date : 2008-06-22
Age : 21
Location : VT

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Thu Oct 23, 2008 9:13 am

heres the evidence:
1. Nasuada has been described as beautiful
2. She is intrieged by magic
3. She is aleady great at blocking her mind
4. As the leader of the Varden, she would have acess to the egg once it was rescued from Galby
5. Nasuada has been thinking about marrige in Brisingr, as has Eragon. Coincidence? NO! Good authors such as CP never have coincidence.
6. She's survived this far. What other reason does CP have for keeping her alive?
7. She has shown so much loyalty to her people; and have muchstrength of character. From the start, she has always been right there in the battle, not hiding on her throne. For example, she stayed behind in the battle of Farthen Dur. Also, she endures the battle of the long knives for her people. This shows that she will have what it takes to become a rider and hlep Eragon confront Murty and Galby.
8. She is extremly wise. She has always done what is right for her people. Even Eragon says (near the begining of Eldest) that she is "wise beyond her years".
9. When Eragon returns from fighting Murty in the end of Eldest, the first thing she does when he enters her tent is fly into his arms. What was Arya doing while Nasuada hugs Eragon? Waiting to leap into his arms and kiss him? No, she mutters some cryptic phrase ("The candle still burns"). Who do you think shows more affection for Eragon?
10. Nasuada is near Eragon's age. She is the only single woman near his age in the series (besides Trianna, but we can all agree that he won't marry her). I mean, he can't marry Arya. She's OVER A HUNDERED YEARS OLDER THAN HIM. It would just be sick and disgusting for an 18 yr old boy to marry a 100+ yr old elf.
11. Speaking of elves, ARYA IS AN ELF. I'm not sure if you noticed that. It is just sick for an elf to marry a human. (1) Elves don't marry. They just take mates for a while, them leave them. Don't you want Eragon to have a long, fuffilling marrige? I'd hate to see him dumped by Arya in 200 years. She would think it natuaral, since that's just what elves do, but Eragon (since he's mostly human) would be heartbroken. (2) WHAT WOULD THE KIDS LOOK LIKE?! That's a disturbing mental picture... I mean, don't you want Eragon to have lovely little kids? I'd hate for him to be stuck with elf-and-human-mutant-blob-whatever-half-breed things. I haven't studdied genetics in depth, but it's still obvious that it would not be a pretty sight. (3) Elves may look somewhat similar to humans, but they are so different mentally. When Eragon first touches Arya's mind in book one (and every other time he touches an elf's mind), it feels so vast and alien. It is described as being extremly different from a human's. Eragon and his wife need to be albe to understand and relate to each other, and when the wife has a strangely alien mind, it just doesn't bode well. (there's a whole lot more I could say about the sick human/elf relationship, but this thing is long enough as it is.)
Sorry, I'm going to cut this short now; I've got homework to do and I can't spen too long on here. Anyways, GE, even you can't deny that huge amount of evidence (and that list is just a start).

_________________
-Participant of the "I'm Mad" topic, that shall indeed save EHQ
-JOIN THE CAUSE! Keep the topic at the top of the list, without keeping it off topic, Matt if you're reading this, go there too. If you read it, reply, we need everyone's help!!

here is the link to the topic:
http://eragonheadquarters.forumakers.com/website-content-f11/i-m-mad-hey-matt-please-read-this-t408.htm
just so you know, I'm not Tom.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://eragonhq.com
Rahl

avatar

Posts : 2542
Join date : 2008-06-16
Age : 23
Location : S.C.

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Thu Oct 23, 2008 8:20 pm

Zeb wrote:
geniusevil wrote:
zeb and eragon there is more evidence for e+a and
case are you just saying that to disagree with me?
i dont want you to hold a grudge for the army dispute
so can we just get along?

I don't think that Case is the type of guy to hold a grudge like that. He's just saying that 'cause it's the TRUTH!!! Check here if you don't think I have enough evidence:
http://eragonheadquarters.forumakers.com/brisingr-f3/next-dragonrider-t4-120.htm#17529
Zebs right i don't hold a grudge like that. The army thing is just fun and games.

_________________
Still Case and still want to be called Case.

*Gator*

BP= 14
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.theridersclub.co.cc
Jumpmann

avatar

Posts : 543
Join date : 2008-09-27
Age : 23
Location : in a cake

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Fri Oct 24, 2008 4:50 am

but in a thousand years, eragon will be the right age. and eragon is already a kind of elf/ human hybrid, and he's fine.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Rahl

avatar

Posts : 2542
Join date : 2008-06-16
Age : 23
Location : S.C.

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Fri Oct 24, 2008 5:05 am

But then ayra would be another thousand years old. Ayra will always be another 100 years older.

_________________
Still Case and still want to be called Case.

*Gator*

BP= 14
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.theridersclub.co.cc
DeltaFlip

avatar

Posts : 976
Join date : 2008-06-12
Age : 23
Location : My better reality.

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Fri Oct 24, 2008 6:20 am

eragon5217 wrote:
heres the evidence:
1. Nasuada has been described as beautiful
2. She is intrieged by magic
3. She is aleady great at blocking her mind
4. As the leader of the Varden, she would have acess to the egg once it was rescued from Galby
5. Nasuada has been thinking about marrige in Brisingr, as has Eragon. Coincidence? NO! Good authors such as CP never have coincidence.
6. She's survived this far. What other reason does CP have for keeping her alive?
7. She has shown so much loyalty to her people; and have muchstrength of character. From the start, she has always been right there in the battle, not hiding on her throne. For example, she stayed behind in the battle of Farthen Dur. Also, she endures the battle of the long knives for her people. This shows that she will have what it takes to become a rider and hlep Eragon confront Murty and Galby.
8. She is extremly wise. She has always done what is right for her people. Even Eragon says (near the begining of Eldest) that she is "wise beyond her years".
9. When Eragon returns from fighting Murty in the end of Eldest, the first thing she does when he enters her tent is fly into his arms. What was Arya doing while Nasuada hugs Eragon? Waiting to leap into his arms and kiss him? No, she mutters some cryptic phrase ("The candle still burns"). Who do you think shows more affection for Eragon?
10. Nasuada is near Eragon's age. She is the only single woman near his age in the series (besides Trianna, but we can all agree that he won't marry her). I mean, he can't marry Arya. She's OVER A HUNDERED YEARS OLDER THAN HIM. It would just be sick and disgusting for an 18 yr old boy to marry a 100+ yr old elf.
11. Speaking of elves, ARYA IS AN ELF. I'm not sure if you noticed that. It is just sick for an elf to marry a human. (1) Elves don't marry. They just take mates for a while, them leave them. Don't you want Eragon to have a long, fuffilling marrige? I'd hate to see him dumped by Arya in 200 years. She would think it natuaral, since that's just what elves do, but Eragon (since he's mostly human) would be heartbroken. (2) WHAT WOULD THE KIDS LOOK LIKE?! That's a disturbing mental picture... I mean, don't you want Eragon to have lovely little kids? I'd hate for him to be stuck with elf-and-human-mutant-blob-whatever-half-breed things. I haven't studdied genetics in depth, but it's still obvious that it would not be a pretty sight. (3) Elves may look somewhat similar to humans, but they are so different mentally. When Eragon first touches Arya's mind in book one (and every other time he touches an elf's mind), it feels so vast and alien. It is described as being extremly different from a human's. Eragon and his wife need to be albe to understand and relate to each other, and when the wife has a strangely alien mind, it just doesn't bode well. (there's a whole lot more I could say about the sick human/elf relationship, but this thing is long enough as it is.)
Sorry, I'm going to cut this short now; I've got homework to do and I can't spen too long on here. Anyways, GE, even you can't deny that huge amount of evidence (and that list is just a start).

Half of that is really not evidence that Nasuada and Eragon will get together. That's just about Nasuada becoming a DR. Does nobody share my views of there being equal evidence for either one? I mean, the only reason I don't stick up all my self-implied evidence for both of them, not just one of them, is because I'm just to lazy.

_________________
"No time for goodbyes," he said, as he faded away. Don't put your life in someone's hands, they're bound to steal it away.
"Don't hide your mistakes 'cause they'll find you, burn you," then he said.
"If you want to get out alive, oh-oh, run for your life.
If you want to get out alive, oh-oh, run for your life."


3DG
Back to top Go down
View user profile
DeltaFlip

avatar

Posts : 976
Join date : 2008-06-12
Age : 23
Location : My better reality.

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Fri Oct 24, 2008 6:28 am

Case wrote:
But then ayra would be another thousand years old. Ayra will always be another 100 years older.

82 years older. And if they're both 1000, 100 will seem like so little amount of time to them.

_________________
"No time for goodbyes," he said, as he faded away. Don't put your life in someone's hands, they're bound to steal it away.
"Don't hide your mistakes 'cause they'll find you, burn you," then he said.
"If you want to get out alive, oh-oh, run for your life.
If you want to get out alive, oh-oh, run for your life."


3DG
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Zeb
Administrator
Administrator
avatar

Posts : 4559
Join date : 2008-05-29
Age : 23
Location : Texas

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Fri Oct 24, 2008 11:49 am

DeltaFlip wrote:
eragon5217 wrote:
heres the evidence:
1. Nasuada has been described as beautiful
2. She is intrieged by magic
3. She is aleady great at blocking her mind
4. As the leader of the Varden, she would have acess to the egg once it was rescued from Galby
5. Nasuada has been thinking about marrige in Brisingr, as has Eragon. Coincidence? NO! Good authors such as CP never have coincidence.
6. She's survived this far. What other reason does CP have for keeping her alive?
7. She has shown so much loyalty to her people; and have muchstrength of character. From the start, she has always been right there in the battle, not hiding on her throne. For example, she stayed behind in the battle of Farthen Dur. Also, she endures the battle of the long knives for her people. This shows that she will have what it takes to become a rider and hlep Eragon confront Murty and Galby.
8. She is extremly wise. She has always done what is right for her people. Even Eragon says (near the begining of Eldest) that she is "wise beyond her years".
9. When Eragon returns from fighting Murty in the end of Eldest, the first thing she does when he enters her tent is fly into his arms. What was Arya doing while Nasuada hugs Eragon? Waiting to leap into his arms and kiss him? No, she mutters some cryptic phrase ("The candle still burns"). Who do you think shows more affection for Eragon?
10. Nasuada is near Eragon's age. She is the only single woman near his age in the series (besides Trianna, but we can all agree that he won't marry her). I mean, he can't marry Arya. She's OVER A HUNDERED YEARS OLDER THAN HIM. It would just be sick and disgusting for an 18 yr old boy to marry a 100+ yr old elf.
11. Speaking of elves, ARYA IS AN ELF. I'm not sure if you noticed that. It is just sick for an elf to marry a human. (1) Elves don't marry. They just take mates for a while, them leave them. Don't you want Eragon to have a long, fuffilling marrige? I'd hate to see him dumped by Arya in 200 years. She would think it natuaral, since that's just what elves do, but Eragon (since he's mostly human) would be heartbroken. (2) WHAT WOULD THE KIDS LOOK LIKE?! That's a disturbing mental picture... I mean, don't you want Eragon to have lovely little kids? I'd hate for him to be stuck with elf-and-human-mutant-blob-whatever-half-breed things. I haven't studdied genetics in depth, but it's still obvious that it would not be a pretty sight. (3) Elves may look somewhat similar to humans, but they are so different mentally. When Eragon first touches Arya's mind in book one (and every other time he touches an elf's mind), it feels so vast and alien. It is described as being extremly different from a human's. Eragon and his wife need to be albe to understand and relate to each other, and when the wife has a strangely alien mind, it just doesn't bode well. (there's a whole lot more I could say about the sick human/elf relationship, but this thing is long enough as it is.)
Sorry, I'm going to cut this short now; I've got homework to do and I can't spen too long on here. Anyways, GE, even you can't deny that huge amount of evidence (and that list is just a start).

Half of that is really not evidence that Nasuada and Eragon will get together. That's just about Nasuada becoming a DR. Does nobody share my views of there being equal evidence for either one? I mean, the only reason I don't stick up all my self-implied evidence for both of them, not just one of them, is because I'm just to lazy.

You're right, half of it is for Nasuada becoming a Rider. But we know that Eragon will marry the next Rider (from some clues that Saph said and the Deathwatch dream). So that's just as goo evidence. And, even if you don't count that (which you should, but if you're too stubborn to see reason), half is still cold, hard evidence, which is more than you can say, Mr. I'm-just-too-lazy.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Rahl

avatar

Posts : 2542
Join date : 2008-06-16
Age : 23
Location : S.C.

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Fri Oct 24, 2008 7:42 pm

DeltaFlip wrote:
Case wrote:
But then ayra would be another thousand years old. Ayra will always be another 100 years older.

82 years older. And if they're both 1000, 100 will seem like so little amount of time to them.
We aren't working with precise age just an example

_________________
Still Case and still want to be called Case.

*Gator*

BP= 14
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.theridersclub.co.cc
geniusevil

avatar

Posts : 954
Join date : 2008-10-14
Age : 23
Location : somewhere, sometimes between heaven and hell, but only sometimes

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Fri Oct 24, 2008 11:50 pm

yes if arya is 1100 and eragon is 1018, he is 93%of her age
that would be like a 45 year old marrying a 42 year old
(which is normal)
(and they could be married in the prologue, zeb who I know is going to say that book 4 ends with the deathwatch dream with roran)

(Sorry about sp and unclearness, i jus had a sedated MRI, it is hard to type and spell after that)
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://eragonhq.com
Rahl

avatar

Posts : 2542
Join date : 2008-06-16
Age : 23
Location : S.C.

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sat Oct 25, 2008 12:30 am

And i agree with him.

_________________
Still Case and still want to be called Case.

*Gator*

BP= 14
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.theridersclub.co.cc
eragon5217

avatar

Posts : 3010
Join date : 2008-06-22
Age : 21
Location : VT

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sat Oct 25, 2008 4:50 am

geniusevil wrote:
yes if arya is 1100 and eragon is 1018, he is 93%of her age
that would be like a 45 year old marrying a 42 year old
(which is normal)
(and they could be married in the prologue, zeb who I know is going to say that book 4 ends with the deathwatch dream with roran)

(Sorry about sp and unclearness, i jus had a sedated MRI, it is hard to type and spell after that)
But if you just had a MRI how do you know you got the math right???? Anyways have you not read Zeb's evidence? Your just like me when I though Eragon=Arya= I love you but then Zeb showed me common sense like I'm trying to show you? Don't you see? It has to be Nasuada!

_________________
-Participant of the "I'm Mad" topic, that shall indeed save EHQ
-JOIN THE CAUSE! Keep the topic at the top of the list, without keeping it off topic, Matt if you're reading this, go there too. If you read it, reply, we need everyone's help!!

here is the link to the topic:
http://eragonheadquarters.forumakers.com/website-content-f11/i-m-mad-hey-matt-please-read-this-t408.htm
just so you know, I'm not Tom.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://eragonhq.com
DeltaFlip

avatar

Posts : 976
Join date : 2008-06-12
Age : 23
Location : My better reality.

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sat Oct 25, 2008 5:48 am

EQUALLY LIKELY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And what if the next DR's a guy?

_________________
"No time for goodbyes," he said, as he faded away. Don't put your life in someone's hands, they're bound to steal it away.
"Don't hide your mistakes 'cause they'll find you, burn you," then he said.
"If you want to get out alive, oh-oh, run for your life.
If you want to get out alive, oh-oh, run for your life."


3DG
Back to top Go down
View user profile
DeltaFlip

avatar

Posts : 976
Join date : 2008-06-12
Age : 23
Location : My better reality.

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sat Oct 25, 2008 5:49 am

Zeb wrote:
DeltaFlip wrote:
eragon5217 wrote:
heres the evidence:
1. Nasuada has been described as beautiful
2. She is intrieged by magic
3. She is aleady great at blocking her mind
4. As the leader of the Varden, she would have acess to the egg once it was rescued from Galby
5. Nasuada has been thinking about marrige in Brisingr, as has Eragon. Coincidence? NO! Good authors such as CP never have coincidence.
6. She's survived this far. What other reason does CP have for keeping her alive?
7. She has shown so much loyalty to her people; and have muchstrength of character. From the start, she has always been right there in the battle, not hiding on her throne. For example, she stayed behind in the battle of Farthen Dur. Also, she endures the battle of the long knives for her people. This shows that she will have what it takes to become a rider and hlep Eragon confront Murty and Galby.
8. She is extremly wise. She has always done what is right for her people. Even Eragon says (near the begining of Eldest) that she is "wise beyond her years".
9. When Eragon returns from fighting Murty in the end of Eldest, the first thing she does when he enters her tent is fly into his arms. What was Arya doing while Nasuada hugs Eragon? Waiting to leap into his arms and kiss him? No, she mutters some cryptic phrase ("The candle still burns"). Who do you think shows more affection for Eragon?
10. Nasuada is near Eragon's age. She is the only single woman near his age in the series (besides Trianna, but we can all agree that he won't marry her). I mean, he can't marry Arya. She's OVER A HUNDERED YEARS OLDER THAN HIM. It would just be sick and disgusting for an 18 yr old boy to marry a 100+ yr old elf.
11. Speaking of elves, ARYA IS AN ELF. I'm not sure if you noticed that. It is just sick for an elf to marry a human. (1) Elves don't marry. They just take mates for a while, them leave them. Don't you want Eragon to have a long, fuffilling marrige? I'd hate to see him dumped by Arya in 200 years. She would think it natuaral, since that's just what elves do, but Eragon (since he's mostly human) would be heartbroken. (2) WHAT WOULD THE KIDS LOOK LIKE?! That's a disturbing mental picture... I mean, don't you want Eragon to have lovely little kids? I'd hate for him to be stuck with elf-and-human-mutant-blob-whatever-half-breed things. I haven't studdied genetics in depth, but it's still obvious that it would not be a pretty sight. (3) Elves may look somewhat similar to humans, but they are so different mentally. When Eragon first touches Arya's mind in book one (and every other time he touches an elf's mind), it feels so vast and alien. It is described as being extremly different from a human's. Eragon and his wife need to be albe to understand and relate to each other, and when the wife has a strangely alien mind, it just doesn't bode well. (there's a whole lot more I could say about the sick human/elf relationship, but this thing is long enough as it is.)
Sorry, I'm going to cut this short now; I've got homework to do and I can't spen too long on here. Anyways, GE, even you can't deny that huge amount of evidence (and that list is just a start).

Half of that is really not evidence that Nasuada and Eragon will get together. That's just about Nasuada becoming a DR. Does nobody share my views of there being equal evidence for either one? I mean, the only reason I don't stick up all my self-implied evidence for both of them, not just one of them, is because I'm just to lazy.

You're right, half of it is for Nasuada becoming a Rider. But we know that Eragon will marry the next Rider (from some clues that Saph said and the Deathwatch dream). So that's just as goo evidence. And, even if you don't count that (which you should, but if you're too stubborn to see reason), half is still cold, hard evidence, which is more than you can say, Mr. I'm-just-too-lazy.

You make it sound like I'm just to lazy to post evidence about just Arya.

And some of the evidence about the fact that Arya's an elf is really just excuses. And when good authors use "coincidences", as Zeb calls it, it's called foreshadowing.

_________________
"No time for goodbyes," he said, as he faded away. Don't put your life in someone's hands, they're bound to steal it away.
"Don't hide your mistakes 'cause they'll find you, burn you," then he said.
"If you want to get out alive, oh-oh, run for your life.
If you want to get out alive, oh-oh, run for your life."


3DG
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Zeb
Administrator
Administrator
avatar

Posts : 4559
Join date : 2008-05-29
Age : 23
Location : Texas

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sat Oct 25, 2008 9:26 am

DeltaFlip wrote:
Zeb wrote:
DeltaFlip wrote:
eragon5217 wrote:
heres the evidence:
1. Nasuada has been described as beautiful
2. She is intrieged by magic
3. She is aleady great at blocking her mind
4. As the leader of the Varden, she would have acess to the egg once it was rescued from Galby
5. Nasuada has been thinking about marrige in Brisingr, as has Eragon. Coincidence? NO! Good authors such as CP never have coincidence.
6. She's survived this far. What other reason does CP have for keeping her alive?
7. She has shown so much loyalty to her people; and have muchstrength of character. From the start, she has always been right there in the battle, not hiding on her throne. For example, she stayed behind in the battle of Farthen Dur. Also, she endures the battle of the long knives for her people. This shows that she will have what it takes to become a rider and hlep Eragon confront Murty and Galby.
8. She is extremly wise. She has always done what is right for her people. Even Eragon says (near the begining of Eldest) that she is "wise beyond her years".
9. When Eragon returns from fighting Murty in the end of Eldest, the first thing she does when he enters her tent is fly into his arms. What was Arya doing while Nasuada hugs Eragon? Waiting to leap into his arms and kiss him? No, she mutters some cryptic phrase ("The candle still burns"). Who do you think shows more affection for Eragon?
10. Nasuada is near Eragon's age. She is the only single woman near his age in the series (besides Trianna, but we can all agree that he won't marry her). I mean, he can't marry Arya. She's OVER A HUNDERED YEARS OLDER THAN HIM. It would just be sick and disgusting for an 18 yr old boy to marry a 100+ yr old elf.
11. Speaking of elves, ARYA IS AN ELF. I'm not sure if you noticed that. It is just sick for an elf to marry a human. (1) Elves don't marry. They just take mates for a while, them leave them. Don't you want Eragon to have a long, fuffilling marrige? I'd hate to see him dumped by Arya in 200 years. She would think it natuaral, since that's just what elves do, but Eragon (since he's mostly human) would be heartbroken. (2) WHAT WOULD THE KIDS LOOK LIKE?! That's a disturbing mental picture... I mean, don't you want Eragon to have lovely little kids? I'd hate for him to be stuck with elf-and-human-mutant-blob-whatever-half-breed things. I haven't studdied genetics in depth, but it's still obvious that it would not be a pretty sight. (3) Elves may look somewhat similar to humans, but they are so different mentally. When Eragon first touches Arya's mind in book one (and every other time he touches an elf's mind), it feels so vast and alien. It is described as being extremly different from a human's. Eragon and his wife need to be albe to understand and relate to each other, and when the wife has a strangely alien mind, it just doesn't bode well. (there's a whole lot more I could say about the sick human/elf relationship, but this thing is long enough as it is.)
Sorry, I'm going to cut this short now; I've got homework to do and I can't spen too long on here. Anyways, GE, even you can't deny that huge amount of evidence (and that list is just a start).

Half of that is really not evidence that Nasuada and Eragon will get together. That's just about Nasuada becoming a DR. Does nobody share my views of there being equal evidence for either one? I mean, the only reason I don't stick up all my self-implied evidence for both of them, not just one of them, is because I'm just to lazy.

You're right, half of it is for Nasuada becoming a Rider. But we know that Eragon will marry the next Rider (from some clues that Saph said and the Deathwatch dream). So that's just as goo evidence. And, even if you don't count that (which you should, but if you're too stubborn to see reason), half is still cold, hard evidence, which is more than you can say, Mr. I'm-just-too-lazy.

You make it sound like I'm just to lazy to post evidence about just Arya.

And some of the evidence about the fact that Arya's an elf is really just excuses. And when good authors use "coincidences", as Zeb calls it, it's called foreshadowing.

Yes, I am saying that. Though I'm not trying to be mean about it. You yourself said (exact quote): "I mean, the only reason I don't stick up all my self-implied evidence for both of them, not just one of them, is because I'm just to lazy." So there's no need to accuse me of making false assumptions when you said it too.

JUST EXCUSES?! No, it's cold hard evidence, that's what it is. Don't deny it.

GE, why the......... heck.... would they get marrid in the prolauge?!?! Even if I was abselutly 10000% for Arya+Eragon, I'd want them to wait till at least half way through the book. Arya has never showed any love for Eragon (If you have any contradicting evidence, please share, but you haven't given any.). She's not going to say 'oh, btw, I love you. Let's get married in an hour.'
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Simply Aravelle

avatar

Posts : 3017
Join date : 2008-06-08
Age : 24
Location : Locked away in the castle people call my mind.

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sat Oct 25, 2008 10:14 am

Hmmm...all of you make intersting points. But let me give you my perspective:

Arya has been a retard. We all know this, but just look at eldest. She crushed eragon like an itty bitty bug. She only liked him as a friend, but she never said she flat out DIDNOT like him. She just thought it wouldn't work out becuase of age difference and it would be a distraction. But if you look in brisingr, do you see it? Arya was getting colser to eragon. She's been doing more and more do get closer to him. She also wasn't over that whatshisface (I know his name but I don't want to spoil anyone), so she wasn't ready for another guy. Do you remember that one part where she puts her arm around his waist? Mmmmhhmmm girls don't do that wthout cause. One must understand the female psych to see that.

_________________
#1 Cause of Death in the World: A Broken Heart
Don't make another victim
~---------------------------------------~
Here I am clinging onto dear life, and you're worried about what you're going to wear tomorrow?
~---------------------------------------~
Let mercy come and wash away
What I've done...
~--------------------------------------------~
I see you standing there
Staring at me
I wonder
I worry
I fear
Why do I care?


Last edited by Aravelle on Sat Oct 25, 2008 11:48 pm; edited 1 time in total
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://fanfiction.shurtugal.com/viewuser.php?uid=5139
eragon5217

avatar

Posts : 3010
Join date : 2008-06-22
Age : 21
Location : VT

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sat Oct 25, 2008 9:24 pm

if what? I Also noticed that they grew closer in Brisinger and I am leaning again towards your side but Nasuada+Eragon is still the strongest for me.

_________________
-Participant of the "I'm Mad" topic, that shall indeed save EHQ
-JOIN THE CAUSE! Keep the topic at the top of the list, without keeping it off topic, Matt if you're reading this, go there too. If you read it, reply, we need everyone's help!!

here is the link to the topic:
http://eragonheadquarters.forumakers.com/website-content-f11/i-m-mad-hey-matt-please-read-this-t408.htm
just so you know, I'm not Tom.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://eragonhq.com
Zeb
Administrator
Administrator
avatar

Posts : 4559
Join date : 2008-05-29
Age : 23
Location : Texas

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sun Oct 26, 2008 2:07 am

*hisses* Jack, don't listen to her! She's trying to turn you to the wrong side.

Sam, I'd like to respond to your "She only liked him as a friend, but she never said she flat out DIDNOT like him" comment (wow, this is starting to remind me of the VP debate). In Eldest, Arya said in the ancient language (exact quote) "My feelings for you are of freindship and nothing more". Even if I had ZERO other evidence, this sionks the E/A ship. I'm sorry dear, but this proves my point. You can only say what you beleive to be true, so Arya obviously didn't like Eragon romantically.

And the whole 'arm around the waist' thing is pretty hypocritical when you ignore that Nasuada ran into Eragon's arms after the Battle of the Burning Plains. Sure, you could say "well, freinds like that hug each other a lot. it wasn't neccissarily romantic", wich could be a valid point, except for two key reasons: (1) What did Arya do in this situation? Fling herself into Eragon's arms and say that she was so happy that he was alive? NO! She just stood in the corner and muttered (exact quote) "the candle still burns". Now, I don't know about you, but I really don't think that that's code for "I LOVE YOU" or anything like that. (2) Later in that chapter, Nasuada is said to cups his face in her hands and gazes into his eyes. Sure, I don't know how the female mind works, but if a girl did that to me, I'd think that there may be a bit more than freindship.

Now what is your response, Govoner Pali-- um... I mean, Sam? (no, I'm not trying to compare you to Palin, but this is really reminding me of a debate like that...)
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Jumpmann

avatar

Posts : 543
Join date : 2008-09-27
Age : 23
Location : in a cake

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sun Oct 26, 2008 2:16 am

hm. you may be right, but Arya COULD feel different about eragon NOW. she might have changed her mind.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Zeb
Administrator
Administrator
avatar

Posts : 4559
Join date : 2008-05-29
Age : 23
Location : Texas

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sun Oct 26, 2008 2:20 am

Of course I'm right. (and utterly humble *wink*)

Nah, she's like him as a freind the whole time.


Last edited by Zeb on Mon Oct 27, 2008 12:16 am; edited 1 time in total
Back to top Go down
View user profile
eragon5217

avatar

Posts : 3010
Join date : 2008-06-22
Age : 21
Location : VT

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Sun Oct 26, 2008 3:18 am

yes! Sam see? Arya said it in the AL! That completely throws it off! How are you going to argue that?

_________________
-Participant of the "I'm Mad" topic, that shall indeed save EHQ
-JOIN THE CAUSE! Keep the topic at the top of the list, without keeping it off topic, Matt if you're reading this, go there too. If you read it, reply, we need everyone's help!!

here is the link to the topic:
http://eragonheadquarters.forumakers.com/website-content-f11/i-m-mad-hey-matt-please-read-this-t408.htm
just so you know, I'm not Tom.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://eragonhq.com
Zeb
Administrator
Administrator
avatar

Posts : 4559
Join date : 2008-05-29
Age : 23
Location : Texas

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Mon Oct 27, 2008 12:17 am

Yes, all of your attempts to argue are futile! I WIN!
Back to top Go down
View user profile
eragon5217

avatar

Posts : 3010
Join date : 2008-06-22
Age : 21
Location : VT

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Mon Oct 27, 2008 2:39 am

Zeb wrote:
Yes, all of your attempts to argue are futile! I WIN!
*ahem* You mean we win?

_________________
-Participant of the "I'm Mad" topic, that shall indeed save EHQ
-JOIN THE CAUSE! Keep the topic at the top of the list, without keeping it off topic, Matt if you're reading this, go there too. If you read it, reply, we need everyone's help!!

here is the link to the topic:
http://eragonheadquarters.forumakers.com/website-content-f11/i-m-mad-hey-matt-please-read-this-t408.htm
just so you know, I'm not Tom.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://eragonhq.com
geniusevil

avatar

Posts : 954
Join date : 2008-10-14
Age : 23
Location : somewhere, sometimes between heaven and hell, but only sometimes

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Mon Oct 27, 2008 3:11 am

no you all lose
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://eragonhq.com
eragon5217

avatar

Posts : 3010
Join date : 2008-06-22
Age : 21
Location : VT

PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   Mon Oct 27, 2008 3:26 am

how? SHE SAID IN THE AL!

_________________
-Participant of the "I'm Mad" topic, that shall indeed save EHQ
-JOIN THE CAUSE! Keep the topic at the top of the list, without keeping it off topic, Matt if you're reading this, go there too. If you read it, reply, we need everyone's help!!

here is the link to the topic:
http://eragonheadquarters.forumakers.com/website-content-f11/i-m-mad-hey-matt-please-read-this-t408.htm
just so you know, I'm not Tom.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://eragonhq.com
Sponsored content




PostSubject: Re: Eragon+Nasuada   

Back to top Go down
 
Eragon+Nasuada
Back to top 
Page 6 of 13Go to page : Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 5, 6, 7 ... 11, 12, 13  Next

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Eragon Headquarters Forum :: Book Discussion :: Theories-
Jump to: