Crazy new theory..... Nasuada's mother

Hey guys, I know this might sound crazy, but what if Nasuada and Eragon both have the same mother (Selena)? I know this doesn't follow any basic logic, but if you remember, Nasuada's mother left her when she was young or something like that. I'm not saying Ajihad is Eragon's dad, but maybe Nasuada is Eragon's half-sister. This would kill the theory that has Eragon marrying Nasuada. I really don't know what to think about this one, but if you have any facts that confirm that this theory is false, post them here.

I don't know, that seems kinda weird. I doubt it myself, but it could be a possibility. Seriously, how would Ajihad and Selana meet?

I was think about that the other day, and it goes with and against several of my theries. I have this theory that Ajihad used to work for/with Morzan, and maybe that's where he met and fell in love with Selena. So that works. And it would be interesting for Eragon, Nasuada, and Murtagh to all be half-siblings, especially if Nasuada became the next dragon rider. And all of their fathers (Brom, Ajihad, and Morzan) are dead. But think about Selena. She would have had a kid with, and then abandoned Ajihad and Brom? We don't know much about her character, but.... As for theories that it goes against, only the Nasuada/Eragon ship, and tha (even I must admit) doesn't have THAT much to back it up. So I dunno.
But one other thing that we have to consider is that Nausada is older than Murtagh, who is older than Eragon, so Selena must have fallen in love with Ajihad, then Morzan, then Brom, in that order.
What does everyone else think?

If it was too be backed up then yes they would have had to meet in that order. It would be slightly wierd though tbh but its somthing to think about certainly...

jusst remember that Nasuada has dark skin and if Selena didn't, then she should have lighter skin than her faher, just putting it out there

I haven't studied genetics, but I do know people who have one parent with dark skin, and one with lighter skin, and have very dark, or very light skin.

there is no possible way that CP would do that there would be so many different love triangles the with
selena+morzan=murtagh
selen+(?brom/morzan?)=eragon
selen+ajihad=nasuada
too much stuff goin on there for one book series

I think Selana was only with 2 men. 3 is too much. Besides, CP wouldn't want to creep his fans out by having Nasuada and Eragon be siblings..Those 2 are on COMPLETELY diffrent awesomeness levels. I mean, we all know Eragon is superior! *coughZebcough*

definetly if she did have three men then she was one crazied woman but who knows ..........well have to wait to find out

Its possible but if it is right it would be really weird

toooo wierd infact and i dont think CP would have done that

Yeah sorry Matt but no way.

Well I think that this is a distinct possibility. I wouldn't be suprised at all if this happened.

meh. Sorry Zeb but it doesn't seem likely.

Meh... idk.

I mean theres a possibility but I don't think so.

Okay. I wonder if we'll find out in book 3 or 4...

Hmmm. Maybe book 4 if it's true.

Maybe... I guess we'll just have to wait and find out!

yeah but I don't think it will be Brisinger if it's true.

It may be. Why don't you think so?

Well I think Brisinger will have to much action for that to happen.

Meh, it can't just be BAM BAM BAM! It needs to have lots of mystery, relationships, and such.

I mean not all action and the relationships will be Eragon+Arya and if they don't marry then Eragon will be trying to get her.

Besides, how long does it take for Nasuada to admit that Selena was her mother?