eragon the elf dead or alive

he is yes but i put he is alive, i dont know why

Elliot your a mod! You can put on vote canceling and change your vote! And kaibo I don't think Eragon will meet Eragon the elf. I mean it's a possibility but I don't think so.

He isnt because if he was the elves would have told the present Eragon!

Nelly wrote:

He isnt because if he was the elves would have told the present Eragon!

No, he meant like meeting his Soul in the Vault. I think it's possible, but unlikly...

Yes that's what I meant. Just like I think Arya dieing is a possibility but unlikely. (See Zeb! Being considerite to your theory!)

Wow! Eragon this is a big turn around, Zeb your not getting me to change my mind tho! NO WAY!

Wow! I didn't know you knew how to do that!

Well now you do! And Elliot, I'm not changing my mind. It's still a possibility. I just don't think it's likely at all. But if we're wrong then Zeb can just point and luagh at us saying, "I told you so!" But if we're right we can do the same to Zeb!

Eragon(sr)'s dragon died, so he went to seek a life of solitude in the spine. One day he got bored so he sang to a root and made it twist and turn in a very confusing manner. Eragon(jr) later found that root when he was hunting and had it in his bedroom before Garrows farm was burnt down by the razaac.

I like posting crazy, unthinkable theories.

oh yeah! THATS ABSULTULY CRAZY!

Yes it is! I don't even know what i'm saying yes o. HAHA!

I still don't think so though... Do you really think that's true?

Whats ture?

I really don't think so. It's veeeeeeeeeery unlikly.

I know. Thats why I asked if he thought it was true.

even he probobly doesn't.

yes but then why come up with some random crazy theory?

That is ture.

wait you think it's true? Strange...

There's one factual piece in that theory. Eragon did have a twisted root in his bedroom before the farm burnt down.

And no, I highly doubt it's true.

DeltaFlip wrote:

There's one factual piece in that theory. Eragon did have a twisted root in his bedroom before the farm burnt down.

Well, it was probobly destoyed, and it didn't spurt out golden flames or shine or eat things when Roran touched it or anything magic like that, so I still think it's an impossible theory.

DEAD

Yup! We all agree!

duh he is dead if he is not ill make my avatar a Care Bear uugh